We Can't Wait for Superman to Save Our Schools
The following column was written by Bill Shore and Casey Steinbacher and appeared in the Durham Herald-Sun. We thought it worth sharing with you.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce is coming to Durham today to screen the groundbreaking new film “Waiting for Superman,” and to spark a desperately needed conversation on the state of public education in America.
Waiting for “Superman” tells the story of five children as they try to make their way out of the low-performing public schools to which they are assigned and into charter schools of their choosing. Along the way, viewers are exposed to the low expectations and dismal student achievement results that exist in too many schools — and what they mean for children, their families and communities.
The facts are alarming. Among developed countries, the United States ranks 21st out of 30 in science literacy and 25th out of 30 in mathematics literacy. The achievement gap between low-income and minority students and their peers is gaping. And an astonishing 1.2 million students — about six times the population of the city of Durham —fail to graduate from high school each year.
But the movie is at its most powerful when it goes beyond facts and figures to show the impact of a failing education system on real children, their families and communities. Take, for example, Anthony, a fifth-grader living in Washington, D.C., who wants a different life than the one that caused his father to die from drug addiction. Anthony’s path to a brighter future — acceptance into a high-performing public charter school — will be determined by a lottery. The school to which he is applying has only 24 slots for 61 applicants. This is tragic — and maddening. The obvious question for us and the same question asked in the Leandro case is “Why does Anthony need a lottery to attend a good school”?
North Carolina has long been a leader on education reform. The state was one of the first to embrace academic standards and accountability for schools, and has since placed a particular focus on college and career readiness.
North Carolina aligned its high school standards and graduation requirements with college- and career-ready expectations, and the state is also home to over 70 early college high schools known as “Learn and Earn” schools. These schools are run in partnership with the local high school and the local community college or university, helping students — including those at risk of dropping out — to earn both a high school diploma and up to two years of college credit.
In addition, North Carolina was only one of 12 states to win funding this year under the federal Race to the Top competition, which rewards states with aggressive education reform strategies.
But like all other states, North Carolina has significant work to do to better prepare all of its students for success in college and the workplace. The National Council on Teacher Quality gave North Carolina a “D+” for its state teacher policies, noting that policies for delivering well-prepared teachers and removing ineffective teachers were especially bad.
And, while leaders in North Carolina have been committed to improving student performance in reading and math, achievement is still too low. The National Assessment of Educational Progress found that only 43 percent of fourth grade students and 36 percent of eighth grade students were proficient in math. There is also a wide achievement gap, with minority students underperforming white students by nearly 30 points on fourth and eighth grade reading and math tests. Like every other state, North Carolina has too many students dropping out of high school, a disturbing reality that we must all work to combat.
We send our children into the classroom with an expectation that they will learn and succeed in core academic subjects and ultimately be prepared to enter college or a career upon graduation. For students who are lucky enough to attend strong schools and receive instruction from effective teachers, this is the case. But far too many young Americans are not so fortunate. These students — not all of them low-income — are trapped in low-performing or mediocre schools, often with no way out. While school reform has been debated for years, there’s been too little serious action.
Because a superhero isn’t coming to save our schools, it’s up to every American to expect more from the educational establishment and to do everything possible to support teachers and administrators in order to drastically improve our schools. A good K–12 education isn’t just for the privileged few; it’s the birthright of every American child.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has been at the forefront of efforts to reform K-12 education so that every child is prepared for higher education or productive careers. We continue to advocate for commonsense reforms including greater accountability and innovation in schools, recognizing and rewarding effective teachers and principals who improve student achievement and expanding educational options for students. Regardless of where students attend school, they should expect a top-notch education in order to ensure a brighter future for themselves, their families and their communities.
The Chamber is proud to promote “Waiting for ‘Superman.’” For more information about the film and campaign, visit www.waitingforsuperman.com/action. For more about the Chamber’s education activities, visit www.uschamber.com/icw.
Bill Shore is chairman of the Chamber’s Institute for a Competitive Workforce and director of U.S. community partnerships for GlaxoSmithKline
Casey Steinbacher is president and CEO of the Greater Durham Chamber of Commerce.
© heraldsun.com 2010

as long as parents look at schools as free daycare, the schools will act that way;
the irony of "Leandro" is that he was from an upperclass family and went on to duke and notre dame;
Reply to this
With these abysmal results, you would think that we need to spend more money!! The US is 4th in the world in per pupil spending and way down in the high 20's and thirties in results. We do not get a good return on our expenditures. Obviously, something is done differently in many other countries who spend much less than us and get great results. Look at Canada, for instance... below average per pupil spending and top 5 results in many categories.
Reply to this
The Chamber isn't interested in improving education. They only want to destroy the teacher unions.
Do people honestly believe teachers don't want students to succeed? Get a clue!
http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2010/nov/11/myth-charter-schools/
Reply to this
"... a good education is a birthright of every American child." I totally agree; however, my dislike for this article is when all of the accountability is placed on the teachers. These are men and women who do not see their positions as a "job", but rather as a calling. These people get paid way less than what they are worth. Imagine a sports star who makes $1 million dollars - that would equal 25 teaching positions in many states. Yes, good teachers are called to teach ~ no one in their right mind would put up with all of the junk the federal and state governments throw at them from (federal and state) people who have NO IDEA what it's like to stand in front of 25+ 10 year olds for 6 hours a day. They have no personal experiences with the students who come to school hungry because there's no food at home, or if there is, no one got up to fix it for them; or the students who were verbally, physically, or emotionally abused the night before; or the students who did not sleep the night before because "momma's boyfriend had his friends over and they drank all night"; or the students whose parents don't really care about school because they didn't do well in school; or the students who come to school depressed because mom and/or dad lost his/her job; or the students who, try as hard as they might, get no support from home with homework or whose parents do not attend special school events that other students' parents come to; or the students who see and talk to their teachers more than their own moms or dads. The list could go on and on. WHEN PARENTS ARE MADE TO SHARE IN THE ACCOUNTABILITY OF THEIR CHILD'S EDUCATION, THEN COME BACK AND WRITE YOUR ARTICLE AND SEE WHAT A DRAMATIC DIFFERENCE THEY (PARENTS) CAN MAKE IN THEIR OWN CHILD'S LIFE. Teachers need to be built up and appreciated, not blamed for all of the wrongs. Why doesn't the media focus on the rights that schools and teachers do? What other job position federally mandates 100% proficiency? THANK YOU, TEACHERS, FOR WHAT YOU DO EACH AND EVERY DAY FOR MY CHILDREN AND ALL OTHER CHILDREN!!!
Reply to this
US ranking is low in science and math education because students prefer studying art rather than boring and rote science.
Reply to this